Maybe even over Biles? Or if not atleast 2nd best over Liukin and Miller. Think about it:
2004 Olympics- Had she been healthy all year she makes the U.S Olympic team. No chance in hell she beats Carly in the AA, but maybe a shot at silver over a very subpar/way past prime Khorkina. Atleast bronze in the AA. Probably wins gold on bars since Khorkina fell and Kupets was injured and below par for her. Probably wins bronze on beam and silver on floor too.
2005 worlds- Had she competed and shone in 2004 she for sure is given gold on bars and beam for the same routines on reputation now, even though I think Nastia deserved the wins there. Makes floor finals and wins silver now too (again boosted reputation from Athens).
2006 worlds- Healthy she wins the AA, wins bronze on bars, wins gold on beam, wins silver or gold on floor.
2007 worlds- Healthy she wins the AA, gold on bars, gold on beam, and maybe gold on floor.
2008 Olympics- With Nastia's fall she makes the AA and wins silver behind Shawn. Unless Chelsie's coach/dad protests Shawn's Amanar to be downgraded and she wins gold in AA now. Doesnt make any event finals since her teammates were too strong, well maybe bars but doesnt medal.
This would give her a resume sufficient to put her above Nastia and Shannon, but perhaps not Biles. Although how do 2 Olympic AA silvers and 3 straight World AA titles compare to 3 straight World AA titles and an Olympic AA gold? Had she not screwed up individually at the 2003 worlds after shining in the Team Event she could have an even stronger position.
Could Memmel have been best ever U.S gymnast without her injuries?
2004 Olympics- Had she been healthy all year she makes the U.S Olympic team. No chance in hell she beats Carly in the AA, but maybe a shot at silver over a very subpar/way past prime Khorkina. Atleast bronze in the AA. Probably wins gold on bars since Khorkina fell and Kupets was injured and below par for her. Probably wins bronze on beam and silver on floor too.
2005 worlds- Had she competed and shone in 2004 she for sure is given gold on bars and beam for the same routines on reputation now, even though I think Nastia deserved the wins there. Makes floor finals and wins silver now too (again boosted reputation from Athens).
2006 worlds- Healthy she wins the AA, wins bronze on bars, wins gold on beam, wins silver or gold on floor.
2007 worlds- Healthy she wins the AA, gold on bars, gold on beam, and maybe gold on floor.
2008 Olympics- With Nastia's fall she makes the AA and wins silver behind Shawn. Unless Chelsie's coach/dad protests Shawn's Amanar to be downgraded and she wins gold in AA now. Doesnt make any event finals since her teammates were too strong, well maybe bars but doesnt medal.
This would give her a resume sufficient to put her above Nastia and Shannon, but perhaps not Biles. Although how do 2 Olympic AA silvers and 3 straight World AA titles compare to 3 straight World AA titles and an Olympic AA gold? Had she not screwed up individually at the 2003 worlds after shining in the Team Event she could have an even stronger position.
Aucun commentaire:
Enregistrer un commentaire