jeudi 8 août 2019

Body Positive Guidelines

Has anyone seen the new Body Positive Guidelines set out by Australian Gymnastics?

You can read them if you go to this link, then scroll down the page to open up the document.

http://www.gymnastics.org.au/GA/Athl...6-1b2f7e858979

I was pleasantly surprised to find they were really well thought out. They talk about trying to avoid body-shape comments in general, whether positive or negative, and instead focus on praising an athlete's strength or technique.

They set minimum ages and maximum frequency for body assessments being done, require athlete and parent permission for body assessments to be done, and require athlete and parent permission for that info to be shared with coaches.

They discourage coaches from discussing nutrition plans with athletes, instead recommending that coaches bring in qualified nutritionists.

They recognize that any nutritional or body concerns should be done privately, not in front of others, and they discourage making comparisons between other athletes.

I realize you can type out all the nice, healthy sentences in the world, but you can't ensure coaches actually follow them. However, if you make guidelines like this a requirement for your members, it does give athletes, parents, and the gym organization some teeth in the event a coach fails to follow them.

I don't know if the USA has put out anything like this in any of their new policies, but these would be good ones if they haven't.
Body Positive Guidelines

mercredi 7 août 2019

Olympic Channel Documentary

The first episode of the Olympic Channel's documentary on Hurd, Melnikova and Chen Yile is up:

https://www.olympicchannel.com/en/or...mpression=true

Chen Yile has not seen her family is 2 years. That is a narrative that we hear a lot in fluff pieces - that Chinese gymnasts sacrifice their family and childhood. Not being too familiar with the details of some centralized systems, does anyone know if that rate of seeing family members (for lack of a better way of putting it) is similar for the Russian and Romanian athletes? Is it forbidden for families to see their kids/gymnasts in China during training (before you jump on me for that word, it was "forbidden" for US parents to see their kids at competitions...), or is it a matter of distance and transport? Surely the gymnasts get some holidays off (New Years?) and so could be visited by their families?

It seems like Russian athletes also don't see their families a lot? Melnikova seems like such a sympathetic character, very easy to like. The competition footage of her is really nice.

Cool to see Chow laughing while coaching the gymnasts.
Olympic Channel Documentary

mardi 23 juillet 2019

Marie Claire Article Re: Miss Val...What is Going On?

(EDIT: sorry about the thread title—my computer kept auto correcting my attempted titles to MARIE CLAIRE article :) instead of MARIA CAIRE article—the article is from the LA TIMES..I thought I fixed it but it reverted back before I posted the thread and i don’t know how to edit a thread title)


http://https://www.latimes.com/calif...sions-20190721



Forgive me if this has already been discussed on the board here somewhere, I couldn’t find anything on it. I only heard about this after listening to the Gymcastic podcast, during which Jessica declined to comment due to conflicts of interest and while Spencer did go into some detail about the controversy, he didn’t seem to have any answers or insight regarding the controversy—only questions.

I assumed initially, it was likely just a case where something Miss Val had done something for good and altruistic reasons (however unusual in a characteristically Miss Val way)—that had been misconstrued and swept into the wave of stories that has been coming out for the past few months about college applicants being unfairly admitted as student athletes, whether in exchange for some financial “gift” or other quid-pro-quo, including social/familial connection to an individual in a position to fast-track someone’s acceptance on the basis of their potential as an athletes who could contribute as a member of their team’s roster.

However, after reading the article I was really struck by some of the details that, if they are indeed true, would seem to suggest that, at best, the situation in question was one where Miss Val was aware of an applicant, because of her relationship with the applicant’s uncle, who possessed character traits/strengths with which this prospective student could contribute/or even make herself an asset as a participant within the athletic program in some form/fashion. And even though, it seems pretty evident, Miss Val would have had to have known that contribution wasn’t ever going as an athlete on the gymnastics team, she named Maria Caire as a recruit for the 2016 roster to ensure her place at UCLA, with the intention of moving her to a managerial role as early as possible (where maybe Miss Val did believe this student, for whatever reasons, could make the kind of difference that would justify the way she’d secured her admission.

At worst, I guess, Miss Val used her position to do a favor for a friend—which I know doesn’t begin to compare to similar college admissions revelations of late.

I think I just didn’t think of Miss Val as someone who would ever participate in that type of thing—in any sort of way.

I’m maybe though, as Spencer noted in the podcast, more bothered by all of attempts to suggest that this (now) manager (who, due to a health restriction revealed in pre-season medical tests, never spent a day actually practicing gymnastics with the UCLA team, which has meant that, in the absence of any official or even informal (ie. recollection of other gymnasts of this person ever having set foot in the gym where UCLA claims she’d done her training) record or her having any experience with the sport, is also without the benefit of of her fellow UCLA gymnasts from the 2016 being able to testify to having witnessed her doing gymnastics), I’m think I’m more bothered by the quotes in the article where Miss Val and the UCLA spokesperson attempt to claim this was a legitimate recruit who they believed “could help the team on vault’?? ...even comparing her to Ariana Berlin????

As Spencer mentioned, Miss Val has taken athletes on the team before who she (and they) knew would never compete, but wanted to be a part of the program, of the team, and have been valuable as they have contributed in other ways—why wouldn’t she just frame her answers to the many questions this story has raised in that sort of way? Instead of this whole pile of whatever that seems completely unbelievable...?

The whole thing is just seems really strange and inconsistent with the characterization of this legendary coach that so many gymnasts testify to.

Unless maybe there is a whole other side to what is set out in this article that I’m unaware of?
Thats why I wanted to ask about it here.

Does anyone have any more information regarding this story? Is there something that the Maria Caire article in the LA Times didn’t get right?
Marie Claire Article Re: Miss Val...What is Going On?

vendredi 19 juillet 2019

2019 GK US Classic

Podium training is live. They're having that weird USAG video sound/echo issue.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d1JDPSRR0BI

https://www.usagymclassic.com/
2019 GK US Classic

jeudi 11 juillet 2019

Katelyn Ohashi Wins Best Play at the Espys

And uses the time to read a poem she wrote about women in media, sports, and the world.



https://www.independent.co.uk/life-s...-a9000006.html

She is awesome. Would love to see her go into coaching if she wants.
Katelyn Ohashi Wins Best Play at the Espys

Favorite Routines You've Seen in Person

So, I've been to quite a few elite gym meets since '96 and its lovely whenever you can remember the awe you felt when seeing a routine live, in person. One of my favorites that comes to mind was Shawn Johnson's 2006 beam routine. The main thing was her layout. I see now that form and technique/execution were not terribly stellar, but I still love that layout, lol.



I also remember Lilia Podkopayeva's compulsory floor in 1996. Loved everything about it because I love everything about her gymnastics (mostly):

youtube;_8UQz6pJZu4]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_8UQz6pJZu4

Trying to keep this place a bit livelier than its been. It helps me keep my sanity while I'm at work, lol. Please post your favorite routines you've seen in person.
Favorite Routines You've Seen in Person

samedi 6 juillet 2019

Summer Universiade

There's a link to the competition here:

https://livestream.com/FISU/events/8723838
Summer Universiade